Jay O'Keefe

Jay's Portfolio

As of December 31, 2009

 

  

 
Beginning two months ago I expanded the performance information. I believe you will find it much more useful and practical. Each month you will see the performance for that month, the performance for the year-to date, and the performance for the entire period from January 1, 2000 to date. For simplicity, I have assigned a value of 100 to my portfolio on 1-1-00, hence the title Jay’s PF Index. Later dates show what $100 invested in my portfolio has grown to. In addition, for comparison purposes, you will see my portfolio compared to gold and the DJIA compared to gold for all of these periods of time. I believe these additional performance figures will add valuable perspective to our investment analysis. Here are the performance figures in the new format.
 

V A L U E S

Date
Jay PF
Index
in USD
Gold
Price
in USD
Oz. of
Gold /
1 USD


JPF/Gold


DJIA


Dow/Gold
01-01-2000 100.00 282 0.003546 0.3546 11,497.12 40.7699
01-01-2009 352.28 881 0.001135 0.3999 8,776.39 9.9619
11-30-2009 412.83 1,177 0.000957 0.3507 10,344.84 8.7892
12-31-2009 396.85 1,097 0.000912 0.3618 10,428.05 9.5060
 

P E R F O R M A N C E

Period
Jay PF
% Chg
in USD
Gold %
% Chg
in USD

USD/Gold
% Change

JPF/Gold
% Chg

DJIA
% Chg

Dow/Gold
% Chg
12-01-2009 to 12-31-2009 (Month) -3.87% -6.80% -4.70% 3.14% 0.80% 8.16%
01-01-2009 to 12-31-2009 (Year) 12.65% 24.52% -19.65% -9.53% 18.82% -4.58%
01-01-2000 to 12-31-2009 (Decade) 296.85% 289.01% -74.28% 2.02% -9.30% -76.68%
 
Notes:
(1) "USD/Gold % Change" is simply the reciprocal of the gold price in dollars. You cannot precisely compare the dollar with gold without adjusting for interest. The dollar earns interest. Gold does not. With interest rates near zero, this seems insignificant, but over time it is not. Interest rates must eventually rise. On the other hand, GATA and other experts on gold claim that the price of gold has been artificially manipulated downwards for many years by concentrated short selling on the futures markets. Some experts also believe that a significant percentage of physical gold supposedly held by futures exchanges does not exist. Furthermore, central bankers regularly talk down gold. After all, it competes with their fiat currencies and threatens their job security.
(2) The Dow Jones Industrial Average (DJIA) does not include dividends given to shareholders. These are typically reinvested, but nowadays the dividends are usually quite small. It also does not include the brokerage fees and capital gains taxes that usually accompany investments in the stock market.
 
Interpretation: For the month of December, 2009, my portfolio lost 3.87%, and for the year-to-date, it is up 12.65%. For the entire period 1-1-00 to 12-31-09, my portfolio index increased from 100 to 396.85, a gain of 296.85%, and Gold increased from 282 to 1097, a gain of 289.01%. Thus, I have outperformed gold by 2.71% for the decade-to-date. By the way, my performance of 296.85% for the decade works out to an annual compound rate of growth of 14.8% per year over the ten year period, slightly greater than the growth rate in gold.

Note also that the Dow lost 9.3% in dollars during the decade, but the Dow lost 76.7% for the decade when denominated in Gold. At the beginning of the decade, it took 40 ounces of Gold to buy the Dow. At the end of the decade, you could buy the Dow with just 9.5 ounces of Gold. The chart below, courtesy of JS Mineset, shows this in picture form:

Dow/Gold Ratio, 2000-2009

Other recent useful charts from JS Mineset:

I made five transactions during December. They are listed under Jay’s Recent Transactions, and will be discussed in the comments section below. Here is my portfolio as of December 31, 2009:
 

CASH

30.0%

(MINIMUM 30%) 
(US Treasury Bills 6.6%, HAFGF 1.8%, Bank deposits & Money Market 21.6%) 
GOLD & SILVER 42.7% (MINIMUM 30%) Gold – 15.1% (Swiss 1-oz bars 5.3%, 1-oz Kruggerands 10.1%)
                         Silver – 27.6% (90% coins 18.0%, 1-oz eagles 2.3%, 
                                                1000-oz bars 2.5%, SVRZF 4.8%;
                                                 note: silver was down 8.7% in December)
MINING SHARES 17.5% SSRI 6.7%; GDX 4.3%; SLW 3.3%; SA 1.0%; VGZ 1.3%; AUY 0.9%
NON-GOLD & SILVER PHYSICALS 9.8% Oil & Gas W/I – 9.3% (Non-publicly traded investment)
PUTS & CALLS 0.0%  
TOTAL 100.0%  

Jay O'Keefe's Portfolio, Dec. 31, 2009Comments by Major Allocation

CASH: Last month I mentioned that my cash allocation was 23.9%, or about 6% below my target. I said that I might increase it at some point, but didn’t know when that might be. That time came just before the end of the year. I increased cash to 30%. My main reason for doing so was the conviction that I should be closer to the permanent portfolio plan, which hedges against both inflation and deflation. I was well hedged against inflation, but not so well hedged against deflation. I have many reasons to believe my top experts have 30% or more in cash. Some of them state it. Others make statements which indicate it. In order to increase my cash allocation to 30%, I had to sell other assets to raise the 6%. I am growing less and less enthusiastic about holding commodity ETFs. Studies are showing they are not accurately tracking the performance of the underlying commodities. In addition, there is higher risk in them because they are funded by commodity futures contracts which carry counter-party default risk. It was an easy decision to sell my RJA, RJI and RJN. Don’t misinterpret this action. I am still very bullish on the long term potential of all commodities, but until I can find a way to own them directly (like gold and silver), I don’t consider the risk acceptable. I made up the remainder of the 6% needed to raise cash to 30% by selling a portion of my SVRZF. This was also an easy decision as SVRZF had risen to a 13% premium over its net asset value. I made a profit of about 25% on this sale in four months! If SVRZF’s premium over net asset value continues to increase, I will likely sell more to capture the arbitrage. Note that I have diversified some of my cash out of money market into US Treasury Bills, since starting on September 18, 2009, money market funds were no longer insured by the FDIC. I will probably move some more of my cash into T-Bills, the safest way of holding US dollars.

GOLD AND SILVER: This allocation dropped a little to 42.7% for two reasons. First, in December gold dropped 6.8% and silver dropped 8.7%. Second, the SVRZF sale discussed above. Here’s a question I’m hearing fairly often lately: “Is it time to sell some gold or silver?” Here’s a question put to Richard Russell, and his answer.

RUSSELL WISDOM (from Richard’s Remarks, December 31, 2009, www.dowtheoryletters.com):
 

Question -- Russell, you've been bending our ears about buying gold ever since the year 2000. Out with it, at what point or at what level do I sell my gold or silver?

Answer -- An excellent and important question. The answer (and this may not surprise you) is that you NEVER sell your gold or silver (or platinum, for that matter). These precious metals are an integral part of your estate and net wealth. I don't care what the current price of gold is, gold represents unencumbered wealth.

Let me give you an example from the rich man's standpoint (and remember, this guy didn't get rich by being stupid). The rich man accumulates and holds ten thousand ounces of gold. At one point (such as today) his gold holdings are worth $12 million dollars. He's still rich.

Then gold declines to a price of $700 an ounce during a crushing world deflation. Bankruptcies rule, and the price of anything and everything with debt against it has collapsed. At this point the rich man is holding $7 million worth of gold. The fellow is still very rich. Next comes a run-away inflation and gold climbs to $2500 an ounce. Here the fellow owns $25 million dollars worth of gold. Now he's almost embarrassingly rich, at least in relation to his neighbors.

You see the point. In holding ten thousand ounces of gold, this fellow is always rich, but let's call it shades of rich depending on the economy. So the rich man isn't trying to “beat" or "out-trade" the gold market. He holds his gold as an eternal store of wealth through good times and bad.

There's only one argument against the above thesis. The argument is that gold becomes a "worthless barbarous relic" of a metal. And suddenly, nobody wants gold. How valid is that argument? Five thousand years of history say that argument is wrong. I've said before that the value of gold appears to be etched into the DNA of mankind. There's never been an instance since pre-Biblical times when men didn't lust after gold.

Conclusion -- Learn from the rich man. Never mind today's price of gold; mind how many ounces of gold you own.

Notice this last sentence. There may be times when you sell a portion, or change your allocation to gold and silver, but it should always be in any portfolio using the Permanent Portfolio strategy.

MINING SHARES: My top experts are in general agreement that we are probably not more than half way through the secular bull market in gold, and the blow-off or bubble stage lies well ahead. I have no intention of missing that. That’s when I expect our mining shares will rise exponentially and provide leverage to the gold price. The current correction in gold and silver, which could last from a few weeks to a year or more, could produce some great opportunities in mining shares. I’ll have more to say on this in the future.

NON-GOLD AND SILVER PHYSICALS: I’m down to just one investment in this asset class, my oil and gas producing properties. This is a non-publicly traded investment which produces monthly cash flow. It is a way of directly owning a physical commodity, and I am very bullish on the potential for oil and gas for the next five to ten years at least. If I did not have these direct interests, I would have an investment in one or more of the natural gas royalty trusts (SJT, PGH and PWE would be my current choices).

CONCLUSION: As you can see, my portfolio is becoming simpler. Sometimes simplicity becomes elegant. I am happy to sit with 30% cash, 42.7% gold and silver, 17.5% mining shares and my 9.8% oil and gas interests and wait for further developments. I stand ready to reduce my gold and silver some at higher prices, or take a nice arbitrage profit out of my SVRZF if it is handed to me. I would also consider adding some to my mining shares if this correction carries them to super bargain prices. Otherwise, I’m happy to do nothing in my portfolio, and use the time for far more important things instead.
 


The law of Your mouth is better to me than thousands of coins of gold and silver.

(Psalm 119:72 NKJV)

And let our people also learn to maintain good works, to meet urgent needs, 
that they may not be unfruitful.

(Titus 3:14 NKJV)
 


Bullion Dealers and Bullion Info  |  Practical Ideas on Buying Gold and Silver
 


Jay's Recent Portfolios  | Jay's Working Hypothesis  |  Jay's Recent Transactions  |  Letters from Jay 
Jay's Simple Investing Rules  | Jay's Investment Model  |  Apply for regular e-mail updates
Money, Finance and Investing  |  Some other helpful information  |  Feedback
Biblical Economics - what most people don't know the Bible teaches about economics
All I Have Commanded - an exhaustive list of what Jesus expects of His followers

WORDS WE HOPE TO HEAR ONE DAY
"Well done, good and faithful servant; you were faithful over a few things,
I will make you ruler over many things.  Enter into the joy of your lord"
(Mt. 25:21 NKJV)

 WORDS ABOUT INVESTING
If you have not been faithful in the unrighteous mammon, who will commit to your trust to true riches?" (Lk. 16:11 NKJV)

WORDS OF WARNING
The Apostle Paul wrote, "Now godliness with contentment is great gain. We brought nothing into the world and it is certain that neither can we take anything out. So having food and clothing we will be content with that. But those who want to get rich fall into temptation and a snare and into many foolish and harmful desires, that plunge people into ruin and loss; because the love of money is a root of all kinds of evil; in their greediness some have been led away from the faith and have impaled themselves on many distresses." (1 Tim. 6:6-10 NKJV)

 TERMS OF USE
This information is public domain.  Jesus said, "Freely you have received, so freely give." (Matthew 10:8b)

DISCLAIMER
The information on this page is the responsibility of Mr. E. Jay O'Keefe, but all your decisions are your own responsibility.


This web page was last updated on 03 January 2010 .